It’s just impossible to believe that it’s been ten years, that a kid could be a young teenager and not remember what life was like before.
Everyone has memories of that day. Here are three of mine:
1. Sending Tom Off on the Plane
Early on that Tuesday morning in September, I sent one of my best friends off in a cab to JFK to send him back to LA. Tom had come to visit for a college reunion we were having up in Maine, so he’d come in about a week earlier so that we could drive up together. While we were there, he broke his wrist badly diving for a softball, and spent most of Monday seeing doctors while I traveled around trying to get him some medication for the pain. His intention had been to stay for the week for a job interview, but the doctors recommended he have surgery as soon as possible, and he wanted to do the surgery back in LA.
So that Tuesday morning, he got in a cab bound for JFK. About two hours later, I watched as the second of two planes hit the World Trade Center, and heard of the plane that crashed in Pennsylvania. It wasn’t until early afternoon that I found out that he wasn’t on any of them. His flight was diverted to St. Louis, where he sat with that broken wrist for most of the next week while the air traffic was shut down. But for most of that day, I assumed he was gone.
2. Walking the Streets
Once the enormity of the tragedy became clear, a mass exodus started out of the city. The streets were closed to traffic, so people just simply walked. My wife, then my girlfriend, worked in midtown, but we got in touch with each other through AOL Instant Messenger and worked out that we’d meet in Columbus Circle and I’d walk her to my place.
So I left my apartment and started walking south, mostly against a massing crowd of people who were all going north, away from Ground Zero. Some of them were Manhattanites, on what would be a two or three mile hike, and some of them were from points even further north — the Bronx, even Westchester. What else could they do? Some of them had no place to stay, many of them just wanted to get as far away as they could, and there were no cars, no cabs, no transit. So they walked, all of them quiet, some of them crying, some of them covered in the ashes of the fallen buildings.
As I walked south, getting on 11AM or so, two hours after the first tower fell, I could see stores shutting down for the day, maybe the week. The local Starbucks was closed, a hand-drawn “sad face” making the announcement. The open stores were mostly empty, because who would be shopping? The only people doing any business were the grocery stores, bulging with people stocking up on supplies for what they expected might be a near siege of the city.
But as I walked, I came across the peculiar sight of one retail store doing a booming business, with people lined up out the door. It was a shoe store, and I was momentarily puzzled wondering why people would be buying shoes at a time like this. Then I realized that all the people on line were women. Women who had already walked miles on their high heels, and were desperate to get some comfortable shoes for the long road ahead.
3. The Friday Vigil
I remember that first week after in kind of a blur. Looking back, it’s almost like it happened in a dream. I remember getting back to work on Thursday, following the mayor’s encouragement that we should all get back to our lives. It was ridiculously too early to be back at work. At the time, I was teaching at Fordham Law School, and I got maybe 10 minutes into the class before I simply stopped, seeing the looks on the faces of students who were simply not prepared to discuss property law. So we just talked about how everyone was feeling, how we were holding up.
That Friday, I remember that people started a spontaneous movement to hold a candlelight vigil at sunset throughout the country in memory of the lost. My now-wife and I joined the vigil, going down to the front steps of our brownstone and then walking the two blocks, holding our candles, to the fire station on 83rd street, which had lost one of its firemen.
When we arrived, there was already a crowd up front. It was an electic crowd, a mix of the Upper West Side residents of the area and what seemed like a group of friends and family of the fallen firefighter. As we got there, a man with a guitar was playing a folk tune, many in the crowd singing along. But not the whole crowd. What he was singing was “If I had a Hammer,” a Pete Seeger progressive anthem about the “hammer of justice” and the “bell of freedom,” first sung in support of men prosecuted for advocating the overthrow of the country. And the people singing along were a group of residents, reconstructed lefties, stereotypically former hippies, seemingly oblivious to the monstrously inappropriate gesture of singing a 60s protest song at the vigil for a firefighter killed in a terrorist attack.
The rest of the people, there because of a personal loss, not because they read something on the internet about walking around with a candle, seemed puzzled, not because they knew the historic implications of the song, but more just a reaction to its cheery tempo. But they clearly felt something was amiss, so when the song ended, up started a very different type of anthem started ringing out — chants of “USA, USA, USA” started by a little boy, maybe eight or nine. So now it was the residents’ turn to feel a little uncomfortable, as the sound of the martial chant, equally as inappropriate as a 60s protest song, filled the streets.
I remember thinking in that moment about how people could have such remarkably divergent reactions to the same tragedy. And I thought about that moment many times in the years that followed, as we saw those two perspectives become increasingly polarized in the governmental response to what happened that day.